The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping Review: The Odds Weren’t In This Prequel’s Favor

When The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes hit theaters in 2023, I was hesitant. Did we need a return to the world of Panem? And did we really need to do it through the eyes of the tyrannical President Snow? How could we possibly need another story after the beautiful work Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson did in the original The Hunger Game franchise? But I couldn’t have been more wrong. It ended up becoming my favorite film of the year. There was something so compelling about Coriolanus Snow, brought to life in a tour de force performance by Tom Blyth, and the mystery surrounding Lucy Gray Baird, played by real-life songbird Rachel Zegler. It brought me back to my childhood obsession with The Hunger Games books and movies. When Sunrise on the Reaping was announced, I was more than ready to make The Hunger Games my entire personality all over again. But I didn’t love the book as much as I had hoped. Regardless, I went into the film eager to see how they’d bring it to life. It’s safe to say it does a serviceable job, but this wasn’t my favorite book or movie in the franchise.

The film starts off strong, introducing us to District 12 through the eyes of Haymitch Abernathy on the day of the reaping, which also happens to be his birthday. Joseph Zada brings an innocent charm to him as he spends time with his family and girlfriend Lenore Dove, repeatedly reminding everyone that he doesn’t drink alcohol. It’s a blatant nod to what his character eventually becomes in the original films. When one of the chosen tributes attempts to run away during the Reaping, Haymitch finds himself selected as a replacement. He joins his fellow District 12 tributes Maysilee Donner, Wyatt Callow, and Louella McCoy. I didn’t realize until the scene was over that I was holding my breath. The Reaping is always one of the most fascinating scenes to see take place, especially in this film as it gives us our first look at Plutarch Heavensbee and his ability to spin a situation in the name of storytelling.

Plutarch Heavensbee uses this approach to “help” Haymitch keep Lenore Dove safe and give him time to say goodbye to his family. However, it’s never entirely clear why Haymitch receives special treatment from Plutarch in the first place. This connection was something I felt was missing from the original book too. Jesse Plemons brings layers to the morally gray Plutarch, a camera operator focused on storytelling and editing who understands how easily a narrative can be manipulated. He plays both sides, doing what needs to be done for the greater good of the revolution, even when it comes at someone else’s expense.

The cast is full of new characters and younger versions of familiar faces. Whitney Peak’s Lenore Dove shares similarities with her Covey connection Lucy Gray Baird, but her love for Haymitch is real. It’s an intriguing dynamic to see, one that must be particularly painful for Snow to witness. Ralph Fiennes plays Snow with a sickly, rigid presence, his appearance reflecting his constant poisonings. Glenn Close is delightfully plastic as Drusilla Sickle, who conducts the District 12 Reaping. However, relationships like her estranged marriage to Magno Stift, played by Billy Porter in a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it cameo, aren’t particularly clear unless you’ve read the book.

Elle Fanning radiates optimism as the rising fashion star Effie Trinket. Kieran Culkin gives Caesar Flickerman a sarcastic edge as he tells the tributes how to sell themselves to Capitol viewers. Mckenna Grace is immediately likable as Maysilee Donner, although she is missing some of the coldness that makes her eventual friendship with the other tributes hit harder. Most of the other characters, including Wyatt Callow, Louella McCoy, Lou Lou, Wellie, and the remaining tributes, are woefully underused.

Unfortunately, the film takes a dive once we get to the Games themselves. We’re introduced to a poisoned utopia that is more stunning than dangerous. Everything feels rushed and lackluster, with characters killed off so quickly that their deaths don’t have time to land. I also missed seeing sponsor gifts, which added another layer to the Games and highlighted what Snow brought to the arena in The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes. The Games are supposed to feel like a show, a spectacle designed to entertain the Capitol. Instead, they lack the creativity and imagination that make this franchise so compelling. For a story centered around the Games, it doesn’t deliver.

The final act brings the film back home. Snow realizes the best way to break Haymitch isn’t to kill him, but to make him suffer. It shows just how dangerous life has become, even outside the Games, and the lengths someone will go to maintain control. Haymitch is forced to embrace the “rascal” persona thrust upon him, becoming a shell of his former self. He drinks, acts out, and eventually becomes a hermit. But when there’s nothing left to lose, there’s everything to gain. The final moments offer a satisfying connection back to the original films, giving us one final moment of peace.

All in all, Sunrise on the Reaping is just okay. There are solid first and final acts, but the Games don’t leave enough time for the emotional moments to hit. It ultimately makes the film feel hollow and repetitive, leaving me questioning whether we really needed to see this story told. The more I think about it, the more mixed I feel. It certainly didn’t reinvigorate my love for the franchise the way The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes did.

Kristen Maldonado

Kristen Maldonado is an entertainment journalist, critic, on-camera host, and founder of the outlet Pop Culture Planet. You can find her binge-watching your next favorite TV show, interviewing talent, and championing representation in all forms. She is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved critic, a member of the Critics Choice Association, Latino Entertainment Journalists Association, and the Television Academy, and a 2x Shorty Award winner. She's also been featured on New York Live, NY1, PIX11, Den of Geek, Good Morning America, Insider, MTV, and Glamour.

http://www.youtube.com/kaymaldo
Next
Next

Jennifer Robertson Reflects On Degrassi “Rite of Passage,” Ginny & Georgia Season 4, and Special Bond With Catherine O’Hara